The New York Times, in its “Upshot” feature, has analyzed for the second consecutive year data for some 179 colleges and universities to determine the “economic diversity” of the institutions. What this boils down to is a scoring mechanism that ranks the schools according to the percentage of freshmen who receive Pell Grants and graduate. The grants typically go to students with a family income of $70,000 or less.
Note: Two tables are listed below, the first for public universities and the second for private schools.
The review of access data is also useful for families whose income is greater than 70k. To be included in the analysis and ranking, each school had to have a 2014 five-year grad rate of 75% or more. This information in itself is a handy way to group these schools by grad rate.
Other data elements stand out: only 32 public institutions made the list because of the grad rate threshold, while 147 private schools are on the list. This, too, is useful, but the story is more involved that these figures suggest. The 32 public schools actually have more Pell Grant recipient/graduates (26,690) than the 147 private schools (20,192). The average percentage of freshmen with Pell Grants in the public universities is 17%; for the private schools, 14% of freshmen are recipients.
Publics have lower average net cost for Pell Grant recipients, $16,250 versus $19,986.
One more interesting element is that the amount of endowment per student is far less for public universities. UC Irvine, ranked number 1 in the analysis, has an endowment per student of $11,000; for Princeton, ranked number 18 in economic access, the endowment per student is $2,320,000. It is common for the per student endowment for publics to be only 5-15 percent of that for wealthy private colleges. Nevertheless, the publics do somewhat better relative to private schools in providing economic access. The link to the New York Times report lists the endowment figures for each school.
Rank | Public College or University | Freshmen | Pell % | Total Pell | Net Price |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | University of California-Irvine | 5449 | 0.4 | 2179.6 | 13000 |
2 | University of California-Davis | 5063 | 0.31 | 1569.53 | 14000 |
3 | University of California-Santa Barbara | 4597 | 0.31 | 1425.07 | 14000 |
4 | University of California-San Diego | 5218 | 0.28 | 1461.04 | 13000 |
5 | University of California-Los Angeles | 5684 | 0.28 | 1591.52 | 13000 |
6 | University of Florida | 6348 | 0.24 | 1523.52 | 9000 |
7 | University of California-Berkeley | 4677 | 0.23 | 1075.71 | 13000 |
24 | University of Georgia | 5219 | 0.17 | 887.23 | 13000 |
27 | Rutgers-New Brunswick | 6393 | 0.23 | 1470.39 | 20000 |
29 | Texas A&M-College Station | 9030 | 0.17 | 1535.1 | 14000 |
35 | SUNY at Binghamton | 2585 | 0.2 | 517 | 18000 |
40 | University of Texas at Austin | 7118 | 0.17 | 1210.06 | 17000 |
48 | University of Michigan | 6176 | 0.12 | 741.12 | 12000 |
49 | University of Illinois | 7321 | 0.17 | 1244.57 | 18000 |
54 | Georgia Tech-Main Campus | 2669 | 0.11 | 293.59 | 11000 |
59 | University of Vermont | 2483 | 0.13 | 322.79 | 15000 |
65 | Ohio State-Main Campus | 7121 | 0.15 | 1068.15 | 17000 |
71 | Clemson | 3286 | 0.11 | 361.46 | 14000 |
75 | University of New Hampshire | 2869 | 0.18 | 516.42 | 22000 |
77 | College of William and Mary | 1479 | 0.09 | 133.11 | 11000 |
79 | University of Maryland | 4011 | 0.12 | 481.32 | 15000 |
87 | University of Connecticut | 3741 | 0.14 | 523.74 | 18000 |
91 | SUNY at Geneseo | 1128 | 0.13 | 146.64 | 18000 |
94 | University of Delaware | 4210 | 0.11 | 463.1 | 15000 |
102 | University of Virginia | 3516 | 0.11 | 386.76 | 16000 |
113 | Virginia Tech | 5360 | 0.12 | 643.2 | 18000 |
114 | James Madison | 4199 | 0.1 | 419.9 | 16000 |
116 | University of Wisconsin-Madison | 6323 | 0.1 | 632.3 | 16000 |
118 | The College of New Jersey | 1402 | 0.14 | 196.28 | 22000 |
148 | University of Pittsburgh | 3851 | 0.12 | 462.12 | 26000 |
152 | Penn State-Main Campus | 8005 | 0.11 | 880.55 | 25000 |
157 | Miami University-Oxford | 3637 | 0.09 | 327.33 | 24000 |
Totals | 0.17 | 834.069375 | 16250 |
Rank | Private College or University | Freshmen | Pell % | Students | Net Price |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
8 | Vassar | 662 | 0.22 | 145.64 | 12000 |
9 | Amherst | 466 | 0.2 | 93.2 | 11000 |
10 | Pomona | 396 | 0.18 | 71.28 | 9000 |
11 | Harvard | 1658 | 0.15 | 248.7 | 7000 |
12 | Westminster, Pa. | 302 | 0.27 | 81.54 | 21000 |
14 | Knox | 380 | 0.24 | 91.2 | 19000 |
15 | Davidson | 483 | 0.14 | 67.62 | 7000 |
17 | M.I.T. | 1115 | 0.15 | 167.25 | 9000 |
18 | Princeton | 1284 | 0.13 | 166.92 | 7000 |
19 | Stanford | 1674 | 0.13 | 217.62 | 7000 |
20 | Wellesley | 590 | 0.17 | 100.3 | 12000 |
21 | Columbia | 1476 | 0.15 | 221.4 | 9000 |
22 | Brown | 1542 | 0.16 | 246.72 | 11000 |
23 | Williams | 544 | 0.15 | 81.6 | 10000 |
25 | Moody Bible Institute | 414 | 0.24 | 99.36 | 21000 |
26 | Yale | 1358 | 0.12 | 162.96 | 8000 |
28 | Rice | 976 | 0.14 | 136.64 | 11000 |
30 | Barnard | 576 | 0.18 | 103.68 | 15000 |
31 | Grinnell | 423 | 0.19 | 80.37 | 16000 |
32 | Occidental | 548 | 0.18 | 98.64 | 15000 |
33 | Gustavus Adolphus | 610 | 0.21 | 128.1 | 19000 |
34 | Vanderbilt | 1613 | 0.12 | 193.56 | 9000 |
36 | Haverford | 330 | 0.15 | 49.5 | 13000 |
37 | Hamilton | 491 | 0.16 | 78.56 | 14000 |
38 | Wesleyan | 741 | 0.17 | 125.97 | 16000 |
39 | U. Penn. | 2353 | 0.14 | 329.42 | 13000 |
41 | St. Mary’s, Md. | 383 | 0.16 | 61.28 | 15000 |
42 | College of Saint Benedict | 538 | 0.2 | 107.6 | 21000 |
43 | Duke | 1730 | 0.12 | 207.6 | 12000 |
44 | Claremont McKenna | 337 | 0.12 | 40.44 | 11000 |
45 | Middlebury | 625 | 0.13 | 81.25 | 13000 |
46 | Wheaton, Ill. | 597 | 0.17 | 101.49 | 18000 |
47 | Allegheny | 601 | 0.2 | 120.2 | 22000 |
50 | Clark | 614 | 0.18 | 110.52 | 20000 |
51 | Bowdoin | 497 | 0.12 | 59.64 | 12000 |
52 | Macalester | 555 | 0.15 | 83.25 | 16000 |
53 | Franklin and Marshall | 604 | 0.16 | 96.64 | 17000 |
55 | Dartmouth | 1109 | 0.12 | 133.08 | 12000 |
56 | Swarthmore | 388 | 0.14 | 54.32 | 16000 |
57 | Saint John’s | 497 | 0.17 | 84.49 | 19000 |
58 | Smith | 643 | 0.16 | 102.88 | 18000 |
60 | Brandeis | 833 | 0.17 | 141.61 | 19000 |
61 | Augustana | 627 | 0.17 | 106.59 | 19000 |
62 | Hope | 822 | 0.16 | 131.52 | 19000 |
63 | St. Olaf | 752 | 0.15 | 112.8 | 17000 |
64 | Washington and Lee | 480 | 0.09 | 43.2 | 10000 |
66 | University of Richmond | 805 | 0.13 | 104.65 | 15000 |
67 | Yeshiva | 860 | 0.16 | 137.6 | 19000 |
68 | Colby | 483 | 0.09 | 43.47 | 11000 |
69 | Kalamazoo | 453 | 0.16 | 72.48 | 19000 |
70 | Wofford | 415 | 0.16 | 66.4 | 19000 |
71 | Clemson | 3286 | 0.11 | 361.46 | 14000 |
72 | Northwestern | 2040 | 0.13 | 265.2 | 16000 |
73 | Cornell | 3223 | 0.14 | 451.22 | 17000 |
74 | Denison | 582 | 0.15 | 87.3 | 18000 |
76 | Sewanee | 488 | 0.14 | 68.32 | 18000 |
78 | Juniata | 391 | 0.17 | 66.47 | 21000 |
80 | University of Rochester | 1472 | 0.16 | 235.52 | 20000 |
81 | University of Chicago | 1426 | 0.1 | 142.6 | 13000 |
82 | Reed | 354 | 0.15 | 53.1 | 19000 |
83 | Emory | 1853 | 0.18 | 333.54 | 22000 |
84 | Colgate | 759 | 0.1 | 75.9 | 13000 |
85 | USC | 2920 | 0.17 | 496.4 | 21000 |
86 | Mount Holyoke | 511 | 0.14 | 71.54 | 18000 |
88 | Georgetown | 1593 | 0.12 | 191.16 | 16000 |
89 | Lawrence | 392 | 0.17 | 66.64 | 22000 |
90 | Syracuse | 3476 | 0.19 | 660.44 | 25000 |
92 | DePauw | 641 | 0.15 | 96.15 | 19000 |
93 | Ursinus | 425 | 0.18 | 76.5 | 23000 |
95 | Johns Hopkins | 1390 | 0.12 | 166.8 | 16000 |
96 | St. Lawrence Univ. | 629 | 0.16 | 100.64 | 22000 |
97 | College of the Holy Cross | 719 | 0.15 | 107.85 | 21000 |
98 | Bryn Mawr | 365 | 0.13 | 47.45 | 18000 |
99 | Skidmore | 660 | 0.13 | 85.8 | 18000 |
100 | Elizabethtown | 530 | 0.16 | 84.8 | 22000 |
101 | Siena College | 766 | 0.19 | 145.54 | 26000 |
103 | Illinois Wesleyan | 527 | 0.16 | 84.32 | 22000 |
104 | Carleton | 527 | 0.11 | 57.97 | 16000 |
105 | Notre Dame | 2070 | 0.1 | 207 | 16000 |
106 | Washington & Jefferson | 326 | 0.17 | 55.42 | 23000 |
107 | Luther | 627 | 0.16 | 100.32 | 22000 |
108 | Trinity, Conn. | 604 | 0.1 | 60.4 | 15000 |
109 | Bates | 500 | 0.09 | 45 | 14000 |
110 | Messiah | 648 | 0.16 | 103.68 | 23000 |
111 | Pepperdine | 783 | 0.15 | 117.45 | 22000 |
112 | Lehigh | 1198 | 0.13 | 155.74 | 19000 |
115 | Connecticut College | 489 | 0.12 | 58.68 | 19000 |
117 | Trinity University, Tex. | 534 | 0.12 | 64.08 | 19000 |
119 | Stonehill | 610 | 0.15 | 91.5 | 23000 |
120 | Kenyon | 480 | 0.09 | 43.2 | 16000 |
121 | Colorado College | 522 | 0.1 | 52.2 | 18000 |
122 | Willamette | 545 | 0.17 | 92.65 | 26000 |
123 | Tufts | 1307 | 0.1 | 130.7 | 18000 |
124 | Wheaton, Mass. | 458 | 0.16 | 73.28 | 25000 |
125 | Gettysburg | 703 | 0.12 | 84.36 | 20000 |
126 | Babson | 489 | 0.15 | 73.35 | 24000 |
127 | University of Portland | 835 | 0.16 | 133.6 | 26000 |
128 | Stevens Institute of Tech | 622 | 0.16 | 99.52 | 26000 |
129 | Bentley | 974 | 0.13 | 126.62 | 22000 |
130 | Case Western | 1252 | 0.15 | 187.8 | 25000 |
131 | Creighton | 963 | 0.13 | 125.19 | 24000 |
132 | Oberlin | 780 | 0.08 | 62.4 | 19000 |
133 | Lafayette | 635 | 0.09 | 57.15 | 19000 |
134 | Hobart William Smith | 638 | 0.12 | 76.56 | 23000 |
135 | Centre | 377 | 0.13 | 49.01 | 24000 |
136 | Washington Univ St. Louis | 1595 | 0.07 | 111.65 | 17000 |
137 | Dickinson | 626 | 0.09 | 56.34 | 20000 |
138 | Muhlenberg | 579 | 0.1 | 57.9 | 21000 |
139 | Boston College | 2305 | 0.11 | 253.55 | 23000 |
140 | Fairfield | 963 | 0.11 | 105.93 | 22000 |
141 | Union College | 559 | 0.12 | 67.08 | 24000 |
142 | University of Scranton | 878 | 0.14 | 122.92 | 27000 |
143 | Rhodes | 545 | 0.11 | 59.95 | 23000 |
144 | Wake Forest | 1230 | 0.11 | 135.3 | 23000 |
145 | Loyola University, Maryland | 1096 | 0.12 | 131.52 | 24000 |
146 | Villanova | 1659 | 0.12 | 199.08 | 24000 |
147 | American | 1623 | 0.14 | 227.22 | 28000 |
149 | Gonzaga | 1238 | 0.13 | 160.94 | 27000 |
150 | Marquette | 1989 | 0.13 | 258.57 | 27000 |
151 | George Washington | 2348 | 0.1 | 234.8 | 23000 |
153 | Whitman | 392 | 0.09 | 35.28 | 23000 |
154 | Carnegie Mellon | 1442 | 0.11 | 158.62 | 25000 |
155 | University of Denver | 1399 | 0.12 | 167.88 | 27000 |
156 | N.Y.U. | 5168 | 0.18 | 930.24 | 34000 |
158 | Boston University | 3807 | 0.12 | 456.84 | 27000 |
159 | Ithaca | 1789 | 0.14 | 250.46 | 30000 |
160 | Bucknell | 933 | 0.08 | 74.64 | 23000 |
161 | Furman | 755 | 0.1 | 75.5 | 26000 |
162 | Santa Clara | 1291 | 0.11 | 142.01 | 27000 |
163 | R.P.I. | 1411 | 0.14 | 197.54 | 30000 |
164 | Fordham | 1944 | 0.14 | 272.16 | 31000 |
165 | Northeastern | 2891 | 0.1 | 289.1 | 26000 |
166 | Providence | 1027 | 0.1 | 102.7 | 27000 |
167 | University of Miami | 2115 | 0.12 | 253.8 | 29000 |
168 | Bryant | 890 | 0.13 | 115.7 | 32000 |
169 | Quinnipiac | 1795 | 0.12 | 215.4 | 31000 |
170 | Marist | 1149 | 0.11 | 126.39 | 29000 |
171 | Southern Methodist | 1428 | 0.09 | 128.52 | 27000 |
172 | University of Dayton | 1765 | 0.08 | 141.2 | 27000 |
173 | Worcester Polytechnic Inst | 1103 | 0.11 | 121.33 | 31000 |
174 | Emerson | 862 | 0.12 | 103.44 | 33000 |
175 | Rhode Island School of Design | 455 | 0.15 | 68.25 | 36000 |
176 | Elon | 1475 | 0.07 | 103.25 | 28000 |
177 | Texas Christian | 1935 | 0.06 | 116.1 | 27000 |
178 | University of Puget Sound | 670 | 0.11 | 73.7 | 33000 |
179 | Saint Joseph’s, Pa. | 1272 | 0.07 | 89.04 | 30000 |
Totals | 0.14 | 20192.08 | 19986 |